| 1 | Applicable Flange Standards | 15% | Ability to manufacture and inspect flanges according to the specification required for the project, such as ASME B16.5, ASME B16.47, EN 1092-1, JIS B 2220, or other contract-specified standards. | Current product data sheets, dimensional drawings, standard-compliance statements, and project-specific inspection plans. | Excellent: Multiple international standards supported with controlled drawings |
| 2 | Material Grade and Metallurgy | 14% | Clear control of carbon steel, stainless steel, duplex stainless steel, alloy steel, and other specified materials, including heat treatment and material condition. | Material test certificates, heat-treatment records, chemical analysis, mechanical test results, and applicable material standards such as ASTM or EN specifications. | Excellent: 100% heat-number traceability with third-party verification available |
| 3 | Pressure Class and Size Capability | 12% | Production capability covering the required nominal pipe size, outside diameter, wall interface, pressure class, and temperature conditions without relying on unapproved substitutions. | Dimensional range charts, pressure-class tables, manufacturing process limits, and sample inspection reports. | Excellent: Capability clearly matches the full project size and pressure range |
| 4 | Flange Face and Connection Options | 10% | Availability of the required face and connection types, including weld neck, slip-on, blind, threaded, socket-weld, lap-joint, raised-face, flat-face, and ring-type-joint configurations where applicable. | Approved drawings showing bore dimensions, facing details, drilling patterns, surface finish, and gasket-contact geometry. | Excellent: Complete configuration control with no dimensional ambiguity |
| 5 | Quality Management System | 12% | A documented quality system covering incoming materials, production controls, calibration, nonconformance handling, corrective action, final inspection, and record retention. | Valid quality-management certification, quality manual, internal audit records, calibration certificates, and nonconformance procedures. | Excellent: Certified system supported by recent audit evidence |
| 6 | Inspection and Testing Capability | 10% | Access to dimensional inspection, visual examination, hardness testing, positive material identification, and non-destructive testing when required by the purchase specification. | Inspection and test plans, equipment calibration records, NDT personnel qualifications, test reports, and inspector authorization records. | Excellent: In-house inspection with qualified external testing support |
| 7 | Traceability and Documentation | 10% | Traceable linkage between each finished flange, heat number, raw material certificate, manufacturing route, inspection result, and packing list. | Heat-number markings, traceability matrices, material certificates, final inspection reports, and controlled manufacturing records. | Excellent: Individual or batch-level traceability maintained through delivery |
| 8 | Manufacturing and Process Control | 7% | Controlled forging, casting where permitted, machining, heat treatment, surface finishing, marking, and preservation processes appropriate to the material and application. | Process flow charts, approved procedures, production inspection points, equipment lists, and sample process records. | Excellent: Stable process controls with documented critical parameters |
| 9 | Delivery Reliability and Capacity | 5% | Realistic production scheduling, confirmed capacity for repeat orders, transparent lead-time assumptions, and a documented approach to handling urgent or phased deliveries. | Capacity statements, production schedules, delivery performance records, escalation procedures, and written lead-time commitments. | Excellent: Capacity and delivery dates supported by measurable records |
| 10 | Export Packaging and Technical Support | 5% | Protection against corrosion, impact, moisture, and flange-face damage during international transport, together with responsive engineering and documentation support. | Packaging specifications, preservation procedures, export packing photographs, technical submittals, and documented communication process. | Excellent: Project-specific packaging and complete export documentation |